Tinted Lens ~

See the world through my eyes

Game Review: Pokemon HeartGold and SoulSilver Versions (NDS)



If you haven’t already done so, make sure to pick up your Yay Day 2010 Compliment Card over here!


Game Review: Pokemon HeartGold and SoulSilver Versions

Pokemon HeartGold and SoulSilver Versions

Many people have suggested that the Pokemon series has been going in a downward spiral in the past 6 or so years, after the release of Pokemon Ruby and Sapphire for GBA.  However, many casual and hardcore gamers alike consider Pokemon Gold and Silver [GBC] to be the best games in the franchise.  Pokemon HeartGold and SoulSilver Versions are the Nintendo DS remakes of the classic Game Boy Colour games; but do they do them justice?

Meet Ethan, the playable character.

Being a remake, it is excusable to have a similar plot to the original.  The plot is typical.  You, a new Pokemon trainer, begin your journey across the Johto Region.  You capture and befriend monsters called Pokemon along the way, in which you battle other trainers with.  Each Pokemon has their own type with benefits and limitations.  For example, Totodile is a Water-type crocodile Pokemon, which can easily deal with Fire-type Pokemon such as Cyndaquil but are defeated by Grass-types such as Chikorita.

On this journey, you attempt to collect all 8 badges in the Johto Region, aiming to tackle the Elite 4 at the end – the 4 strongest trainers in the region – and become the Champion.  On the way you will make friends and rivals and thwart the plots of the evil Team Rocket.  Simple, no?

Although appearing quite simple, the Pokemon games are actually quite complex as you delve into them, with numerous strategies able to be employed in the battles and different natures and abilities which affect your Pokemon’s power.

Despite this, the tried and true formula for the franchise is, well, tried and true.  It definitely works, but is a bit…boring.  More of the same.

Walking with Pokemon

However, HeartGold and SoulSilver stand out from the crowd.  Whilst Diamond and Pearl [NDS, 2007] seemed like experiments for the relatively new Nintendo DS, HeartGold and SoulSilver utilise the DS’s capabilities to the maximum with a novel touch screen menu and graphics which, although not spectacular, are a big improvement over the past graphics.

Part of the opening sequence. Yes, you still view most things from the top, but there are some exceptions.

The music in this game is absolutely stunning.  Each different song is a remix of the original, appealing to both new players and those who wish to reminisce.  The game also comes packaged with a little device known as the PokeWalker.  You transfer Pokemon onto it and walk around, with the PokeWalker counting your steps like a pedometer. The more you walk, the more chance you have of encountering a rare Pokemon.  It’s a nice extra, but nothing special.

The Pokeathlon

Also featuring in this game is a series of mini-games known as the Pokeathlon, which use the touch screen.  You pit a team of three Pokemon against other teams in a series of mini-games such as races, catching a disc or breaking blocks.  They use the overworld sprites – did I mention that the first Pokemon in your party can follow you?  This is a very nice addition and emphasises on the game’s theme of friendship and love.

All in all, this is definitely a return to form for the Pokemon series.  I’d even go as far as saying this is the best Pokemon game since Gold and Silver themselves.

Score: 8.8/10




Author: Josh

Josh is a final year Bachelor of Arts student majoring in Politics & International Studies and English & Theatre Studies. He enjoys eating ice cream, jamming to Taylor Swift, and procrastinating on readings.

8 thoughts on “Game Review: Pokemon HeartGold and SoulSilver Versions (NDS)

  1. I believe this is actually the highest rating game I’ve reviewed.

    I have a lot more reviews to write:

    2 more game reviews: Scribblenauts [NDS] and Super Mario Galaxy [Wii]
    1 Book review: Nina of the Dark
    1 Blog review: Poseidon’s Domain

    And I’m about a third of the way through another book. I guess this means there will be lots of reviews in the next few weeks.

  2. “HeartGold and SoulSilver utilise the DS’s capabilities to the maximum”

    Have we all forgotten about the microphone? 😆

    Poketto Monsutā! I choose you! (I heart Pocket Monsters, honest.)

  3. Oh, and an 8.8 score is, indeed, very high. I loved Poketto Monsutā Gold Edition. Haha, I was pretty good. But then my love for Poketto Monsutā all changed… when I couldn’t beat that darn tournament.

    Well, it’s good to see you catching ’em all, Joshua. 😉

  4. I still prefer the original Silver.
    One of my favorite Gameboy Color games.

  5. Microphone? Oh, right, forgot about that :p
    And lol, I think I had some major problems in the wording of this post. It sounds sort of like broken English :/
    8.8 is quite high. But the other two games I will be reviewing in the next week or two are two excellent games. There’s a chance we could see even higher scores.

  6. hmm. they dont have any of the new pokemon in it, do they? It would be awesome if it was just the pokemon that were around during the making of the original game, and would really suck if they included the sh*t pokemon that came afterward.

  7. Up until you become the Champion of Johto after collecting the eight badges, there are only the original 251 Pokemon + 4 or so evolutions of them. After you become the Champion, the newer ones start appearing. They’re less common, though.

  8. This comment is quite delayed. I’ve been in oh-crap-gotta-get-ready-for-band mode xD I LOVE POKEMON. You already know that. I can’t wait for the Black/White release!!! But that’s a buttload of new Pokemon names to learn… I think I’m going to go around and leave more comments everywhere. ^-^

Share your thoughts!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s