Tinted Lens ~

See the world through my eyes

Book Review: City of Ashes (Cassandra Clare)


'City of Ashes', Cassandra Clare

Note: This review contains spoilers for the previous book in the series, City of Bones.


Clarissa Fray is now no longer your everyday teenager.  After discovering she actually has Shadowhunter blood, she has been thrusted into the world of the Shadowhunters, facing demons, Inquisitors and other mystical things.

Her mother is still in a coma, and no matter what they do, they can’t wake her up.  And what’s worse is Valentine, the evil man who is apparently Clary’s long lost father, has the Mortal Cup and will inevitably use it to wreak more havoc, especially since rumours are circulating that he is out to steal the second Mortal Instrument, the Mortal Sword.

Amidst all these worries, there lies an even greater problem for Clary: how can she continue to be madly in love with Jace, and him with her, if they are brother and sister?

City of Ashes did not let me down.  After reading the first instalment, I expected nothing less than an equally thrilling story with a fascinating plot and strong characters.  This is exactly what I received.

The plot was different, in a good way.  I loved how all the subplots worked to form the big plot.  It twisted and turned but remained the focus of the story.  There was clear direction throughout the novel; there were no useless chapters, written just to fill pages.  Humour was expertly juxtaposed with underlying pressures and drama throughout the novel.  It was impossible to put the book down as the plot was that gripping.

The characters were very similar to City of Bones, but also very different.  Clary was still a very strong protagonist.  Jace was quite different to how he was in the previous instalment; he appeared a lot more reserved in this novel than the last.  I personally find their brother-sister romance to be utterly disgusting.  How can you still have feelings for each other despite being brother and sister?  Wouldn’t your repulsion outweigh your attraction?

Simon was a more important character in this book, and I found it to be a step in the right direction as I think he’s quite an interesting character.  He undergoes some major changes in this novel and I’m sure he’ll only grow as a character as time goes on.  Isabelle had a less important role in this book, compared to the last, whilst her brother Alec, who is gay, had a bigger role.  I found the way he acted with Magnus Bane, the mystical warlock, to be interesting and it added some spice to the book.  It was great to see him stepping up.

Overall, this was a wonderful read.  The plot was nothing less than stunning, and the characters were strong and well developed.  Clare’s writing style is unique and loveable, and I can’t wait to read the rest of this series.

Rating: 5/5



Author: Josh

Josh is a final year Bachelor of Arts student majoring in Politics & International Studies and English & Theatre Studies. He enjoys eating ice cream, jamming to Taylor Swift, and procrastinating on readings.

2 thoughts on “Book Review: City of Ashes (Cassandra Clare)

  1. I love this series~
    I haven’t read City of Glass yet, because although I own it someone borrowed it off me, but I plan to read and write and review for CoG before April 5th [the day City of Fallen Angels is apparently coming out] and then read CoFA and write a review as quick as possible.
    So for this series, I’m going to go out of order in terms of which review to write first.
    Reviews that need to be written (ie. books that I’ve read but have not yet written a review, in order)
    -Fallen (Lauren Kate)
    -Hunger (Michael Grant)
    -Uglies (Scott Westerfield)
    -Lies (Michael Grant)
    -Minumum of Two (Tim Winton)
    -Vampire Academy (Richelle Mead)

    With the brother/sister romance I think that you have to consider that they had feelings for one another and THEN they were told that they were related. I think if they had been brought up with the knowledge thatthey were siblings the romance wouldn’t have developed, but since it happened after, the feelings they had for one another didn’t just dissipate. I think it was pretty hard for them to just snap away from their feeling because they are told to.
    I don’t really think they were repulsed by each other either.

    If you’re interested in the issue, V.C. Andrews wrote ‘Flowers in the Attic’ which details (on an extreme level) sibling incest. I haven’t read it myself though.
    So I guess I understand… It’s gross on some levels, but I understand.

    I’m so so so excited for COFA!! 😀
    Glad you’re loving them.

Share your thoughts!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s